Scribner's Magazine
Book Reviews by Eli Siegel 1931-1934

From Scribner's, June 1934

Breathe upon These Slain. By Evelyn Scott. Smith, Haas. $2.50.

One fine thing about Evelyn Scott as a novelist is that one constantly feels that she is compelled to imagine the way she does. There are not in her books the clever little falsities and the adroit superficialities conspicuous elsewhere. Her imagination leads her willy-nilly: she was born to imagine.

     This is clear in Breathe upon These Slain. Mrs. Scott begins an imaginative tour with some photographs and pictures she sees on the walls of a cottage she has rented near the English seacoast. Mrs. Scott tells us she means to use her findings as a starting-point for creation; but we don't feel this is just part of a novelist's technique; a new trick of the fiction-writer in a world where fiction abounds. We feel that this way of writing a novel is a soul's command, though deliberately followed. And as Mrs. Scott tells us of the vagaries of her imagination, appearance and reality seem delightfully and deeply to interchange.

     From what she finds in her English cottage, Mrs. Scott creates an English family and its human and non-human surroundings. From the photograph of four sisters, Mrs. Scott makes four lives, all of which nicely blend with the lives we ourselves have been meeting. There is Tilly, gently intense, who dies young, and whose dying comes again and again into the lives of those who live on. There is Ethel, whose love confuses her and other people for many years. There is the attractively matter-of-fact Cora. There is Meg, whose destiny is in her ungainliness. And there is the fussily domineering mother, Fidelia Courtney; and the intricately weak husband, Philip Courtney.   

     Perhaps, however, the high point in characterization of Mrs. Scott's book is the bustling, scheming, stupid, fawning, mighty servant of the family, Annie Rose Roberts. She grayly and luminously shows what a many-spoked wheel character is. And in Mrs. Scott's book there is the war and various suffering warriors and non-warriors. And a Yarmouth mighty unlike the Yarmouth of Dickens's David Copperfield. And many seas and many weathers. And people living gently and hatingly among themselves. And a termination, which, like the termination of life, doesn't really terminate.

Eli Siegel.

Reviews by Eli Siegel from Scribner's Magazines 1931-1934. Copyright 1931, 1932, 1933, 1934 Charles Scribner's Sons; copyrights renewed. Reprinted with the permission of Charles Scribner's Sons.

More Scribner's Reviews by Eli Siegel

arrowA Calendar of Sin by Evelyn Scott
arrowMark Twain's America by Bernard DeVoto
arrowTragic America by Theodore Dreiser
arrowThe Road Leads On by Knut Hamsun
arrowEva Gay by Evelyn Scott
arrowThe Life of Emerson by Van Wyck Brooks
arrowAdventures in Genius by Will Durant
arrowAnn Vickers by Sinclair Lewis
arrowBreathe Upon These Slain by Evelyn Scott
arrowThe Sheltered Life by Ellen Glasgow

arrowEimi by E.E. Cummings
arrowJohn Dryden by T.S. Eliot
arrowSelected Essays
: 1917-1932 by T.S. Eliot
arrowThe First Wife
and Other Stories by Pearl S. Buck
arrowThe Sibyl of the North: The Tale of Christina, Queen of Sweden
by Faith Compton Mackenzie
arrowThe Soul of America by Arthur Hobson Quinn
arrowThree Cities: A Trilogy by Sholom Asch
arrowEdmund Kean by Harold Newcomb Hillebrand
arrowWilliam Carlos Williams: Collected Poems, 1921-1931
arrowA Cultural History of the Modern Age by Egon Friedell, Vol. II
arrowThe Proud and the Meek (Men of Good Will, Part II) by Jules Romains
arrowThe Proud and the Meek (Men of Good Will, vol. III) by Jules Romains


Aesthetic Realism Foundation
Definition Press Books
Terrain Gallery of the Aesthetic Realism Foundation
Friends of Aesthetic Realism—Countering the Lies
More about Ellen Reiss
More about Eli Siegel

Events   |  About Us  |  Classes  |  Resources
Teaching Method
  |  Contact