• Skip to main content

Aesthetic Realism Online Library

Home > Reviews > The First Wife And Other Stories, by Pearl S. Buck

Scribner’s Magazine

Book Reviews by Eli Siegel 1931-1934

The First Wife and Other Stories, by Pearl S. Buck.

John Day. $2.50.

China is met by the mind of a true writer in the stories of Mrs. Buck, and that is the chief reason why thousands of Americans are becoming somewhat China-wise. For Mrs. Buck, willy-nilly, gives every written paragraph a paragraph’s worth of mind; and if her subject is China (it might have been something else), why, that dimly and ignobly seen land may be considered literarily fortunate.

The First Wife is made up of stories showing how hearts are revolutionized when a country is; how China, with all its millions of tremendously anonymous people, has emotions to provide for each; and how, in a fashion, every one of these emotions is understandable and right—just as they are in Iowa or Brooklyn. Fathers are put into a great mournfulness by their sons who have been in the West and do not care for the solemn accumulations of family custom in China; serenely suffering Chinese wives kill themselves because of the strangeness and unwilling cruelty of their husbands who have seen trolley-cars and, perhaps, adding-machines; old mothers suffer; and sons suffer at the hands of their slow-proceeding parents. The China that changes is a China that suffers: from love, from floods, from hunger.

Mrs. Buck has no ups and downs, aesthetically. She has been deeply taken by existence; and one part of existence, little understood by the Atlantic, she has made her own; and she knows her territory. She doesn’t fumble; she doesn’t get vaporish; she goes off into no flamboyant thinnesses, no gorgeous vacancies or intense failures.

Her Chinese have been seen; she has captured her landscapes. But all this is because somewhere she worshipped reality and the word that can have reality in it. And a multitudinous Oriental people got in a writer’s way later.

I feel, from The First Wife and Other Stories, that sometimes immense, sensational popularity is explainable and most honorable. In Mrs. Buck’s book, China, reality, and the word make a grand private and public combination.

Eli Siegel.
1933

Reviews by Eli Siegel from Scribner's Magazines 1931-1934. Copyright 1931, 1932, 1933, 1934 Charles Scribner's Sons; copyrights renewed. Reprinted with the permission of Charles Scribner's Sons.

Stay in touch

Receive email alerts for each new issue of The Right Of, and announcements of events at the Aesthetic Realism Foundation.

Subscribe

Follow us:   

Contact Us Support Our Work

Aesthetic Realism Foundation
141 Greene Street
New York, NY 10012
tel 212.777.4490

Copyright © 1997-2025 Aesthetic Realism Foundation

MENU
  • Home
  • Periodical (TRO)
    • Current Issue
    • Drama & Acting
    • Literature & Poetry
    • Love
    • Mind
    • Music
    • Teaching Method
    • The Visual Arts
    • Archive
  • Poetry
    • Poems by Eli Siegel
      • Short Poems
      • Civil War Poems
    • Translations with Notes
    • Poets: Their Lives & Works
    • What Poetry Really Is
    • The Critical Muse
    • Critics Speak
    • A Celebration of Poetry
    • Poetry of Martha Baird
  • Books
  • Essays
  • Lectures
  • Definitions
  • Reviews
  • News Archive
    • Educational Method
    • Love & the Family
    • Art & Life
    • More Issues of Our Time
  • The Eli Siegel Collection
  • Aesthetic Realism Fdn.
  • Terrain Gallery